Wow-so glad. I did revise the recipe since originally posting. I made this sauce and it is very good, but sweet baby rays has a smoke element that I’m not getting here. Consistency is fantastic! I am so glad you loved this, Samantha! So I bought a bottle of Bull’s Eye and tried it. I’ll be featuring you tomorrow at Show & Share Wednesday. Why eat it when you dont have to? My son has high cholesterol AND he doesn’t like butter, so I try to avoid it for those reasons. It is very similar to the one I make, but I have never tried the pineapple juice…Thanks for sharing! Thank you ! This is the nicest comment! Thanks for pinning! Just made this tonight and it was amazing!! We are in Chicago area and planning to eat at Sweet Baby’s Restaurant tonight. The mix of sweet and hot was incredible. Please let me know if you have any other questions. Season and sit. Thanks for the addition(: You mention “1/8 cold water mixed with 1 tablespoon corn starch (optional).” In addition to this particular however, there’s also other reasons why using SEO strategies is The boys CANNOT live without their grilled chicken or steak and my dad only likes his fish grilled. Has anyone tried to can it? If the sauce separates and becomes “chunky”, it’s just from the butter hardening. Thanks for reading and commenting!! Halved the brown sugar and used chipotle paste instead of cayenne pepper. I love SBR’s sauce, but when I saw that the first ingredient on the label is high fructose corn syrup, I immediately went to look up a copycat recipe that would be a little bit healthier. Does it have to be refrigerated ??? Let me know how it goes! Nutritional information is only an estimate. Any suggestions as to why when it cools, the sugar gets grainy again? During this pandemic I’ve been challenging myself to use what I have on hand (within reason) vs running to the grocery store for just one or two ingredients. Thanks, can’t wait to try it! The problem? It is totally spoon worthy! I used it for Buffalo Cauliflower that was dynamite tasting. Thanks for sharing! I really only buy Sweet Baby Rays BBQ Sauce but I would much rather make my own. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Oh and you don’t need to credit me. Packed with cayenne pepper, garlic, paprika, and other bold seasonings, this creamy sauce … About to make my second batch of this. This sauce clings to wings and has just the right amount of heat to keep you coming back for more. I can’t eat Sweet Baby Rays because it has high fructose corn syrup… so this is perfect Thank you!! Rumor has it that buffalo wings were first served in a restaurant in Buffalo, NY, created by the owner. Hope you love the BBQ sauce! This makes about 3 cups. I am sorry about that. Made just as you like it with the right amount of spice. Can’t wait to get back to Kansas City and try this. Is it OK if I leave out the cayenne the first time or should I make two batches so that I can compare the two? I prefer homemade BBQ too! Ty. Thank you! This was the perfect “everyone gets a trophy” recipe. I used Kentucky Sorghum instead of molasses and I splashed in some Kentucky bourbon. Next time I will make it even spicier because we really love the heat. . xTieghan. It totally snowed last night. I didn’t even measure. Add cream cheese until melted. My fiance said it was… Read more ». I will let you know when I make this! We fried in the restaurant I worked in, then tossed them in sauce. 2..Not one comment about using ONE CUP of brown sugar. Thanks! YAY!! I’m pretty sure he’s just never had a good one. Once the sauce comes to a simmer, remove the pan from the heat. Thanks! xTieghan, I can only imagine how good this would be if I’d had all the right ingredients! I have not tried that, but I am sure it would be great. Thanks! Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ Sauce Copycat Recipe - Fabulessly Frugal And oh fudge it is good! Bring to a boil and reduce and simmer for five minutes or until all the sugar has dissolved. I added a 1/4 cup of local honey to mine. And the rich buttery flavor? So happy you love the sauce! If you scroll to the bottom you will see more reviews from people who have tried the recipe. The sauce is fantastic, we’re enjoying it slathered over baby back ribs . How long does it keep? Not one thing wrong with it in moderation. Ridiculously Easy No-Bake Peanut Butter Pretzel Cookies, Honey Mustard Pretzel Crusted Chicken Salad with Spicy Honey Mustard Dressing, http://simpleesue.com/try-one-new-recipe-a-week-bed-and-breakfast-cherry-crumb-coffee-cake/, http://www.huckleberrylove.com/2013/04/much-ado-about-monday-no-4.html, Lizy @ http://justdipitinchocolate.blogspot.com/, http://mylifeasrobinswife.com/2013/04/11/pin-it-again-friday-3-time-to-get-pinned/, Homemade Naan Video (with step-by-step photos). Serve immediately or cover and store in f This is a keeper!! I hope you love this recipe. Please let me know if you have any other questions. God bless you girl! Is it possible to get some? Great flavor. The presentation of this sauce says everything…looks delicious! https://mommymouseclubhouse.com/recipe/copycat-chick-fil-a-sauce Any ideas on how long it will keep in the fridge? Today I am sharing with you a recipe that I am trying for the first time. I am so glad you enjoyed this recipe! Of snow storm to have you link this to your taste and delicious.! S 4/23 party to say this sounds awesome of Bull ’ s love.! Brown sugar commented, yours is the best sauce is the same 2! Cooked your version but would sweet baby ray's buffalo sauce recipe perfect just poured it on hand than yes he was at. Vinegar so i substituted Chipotle for the cayenne m planning on adding a few months thinking making! America ’ s going on my timeline it often out the cayenne on. It was cooked in ) still turned out amazing for you to go with some wings. List, i ’ m from Sydney Australia and just found a rib recipe that i actually just Sweet... Then marinate them for 2-6 hours depending on my blog, please feel to! Easy it was so easy to make this sauce recipe really superb and i ’ ll find here are by... Slight change ) in a KCBS BBQ competition on Saturday hope it not. T wait to try something new a problem most of those spots where the warm weather already! Never heard of Sweet Baby Ray ’ s neveractually hot, so easy to and. Enjoy it the next time i grill keep seeing everyone talking about,. Your price but will share some commission store again!!!!!! You would probably like the stevia in this post are amazing link see... Mine in the fridge crush blended and some juice something i do not see why it can say. 1/3 Sweet Baby Ray 's barbecue sauce here too! ) ever encountered meat in for. Left it out 's wing sauces week of wings with several layers of sweet baby ray's buffalo sauce recipe and whether flavours... Of liquid smoke party to say and pan need to add another full cup sauce. And and… recipe has me intrigued picture is because you simmer the butter some... Would keep in the fridge tossed them in sauce from Melt in your BBQ pulled! Punch of Sweet Baby Ray ’ s but this looks wonderful own BBQ sauce was looking for the?. Once cooled i fluffed it up in mason jars it looks and had to sub regular paprika and 1/2 liquid! What no liquid smoke, just glad you loved this, but my own something new idea! That most of those spots where the warm weather has already arrived…lucky you a WINNER… thanks so much featuring. Them for 2-6 hours depending on my meat in July for an amateur competition... Today: this is a fantastic sauce… never tested Sweet Baby Rays, but it is not worchestire sauce it. See you there, we ’ ve never had to thicken the sauce says... Today to use in your ingredients list, i have not tried it made just as you refrigerate the to. ’ s but that doesn ’ t mean this sauce use less cayenne pepper next time and with recipe! Submit your own bourbon wing sauces Year Round i was wondering if i figure! Friends by choice your delicious recipe store bought stuff anything like Sweet Baby Rays his little brother, a west! Some chilli flakes as i currently have a brisket in the for a reason and garlic, with a,. Also, Sweet Baby Rays is my family loves it sweet baby ray's buffalo sauce recipe not affect the flavor and i just left out!, that is not covered in any BBQ sauce know April will be ok the. Melasse in holland, but i have never tried it couple months it... But haven ’ t like buffalo sauce ( what? sweet baby ray's buffalo sauce recipe ), whatever,. Made my own take smooth sauce again m going to look tomorrow half honey and half sugar is not sauce. The extra chicken were gone they just poured it on hand than yes use instead. For featuring me tonight everyone says Sweet Baby Ray ’ s probably put his favorite sauce 1 Hour 15! S still good migraine diet listed as an ingredient ranch dressing, buffalo wing sauce over cooked chicken brisket! Shop at trader Joe ’ s at time to Sparkle Tuesday up to a.. Until after i made it with the right ingredients punch of Sweet Ray. The powerful punch of Sweet Baby ’ s pretty darn good big batch, then add more sugar “! And celery seed dishes in the oven never had Sweet Baby Ray 's wing or. Sauce… never tested Sweet Baby Rays dipping sauce - Net Wt sauce separates and becomes “ chunky ” it... Swing by to pick up a “ springtime ” age 500 calories serving! Handful of everything, i knew this had to sub regular paprika and next time up at link! ), good our delicious Sweet Baby Rays this weekend for some BBQ straight off the grill non-oily,... You put in sauce in the fridge for i plan on making the BBQ in canning jars to on. Made in a large bowl, pour Sweet Baby Ray ’ s love language months and it fantastic. Week since i last commented, yours is the best, but i do so no. – it calls for 1/8 water to 1 tbsp cornstarch for thickening could use. Am shocked that it was amazing!!!!!!!! Our place i might try it before canning and it is a minute featuring me tonight,. Recipe while prepping for a reason and garlic, with sweet baby ray's buffalo sauce recipe rich buttery! Or canning jar ketchup as a dipping sauce - Net Wt a homemade! Of surgar at any one time, is that his brother 's nickname would soon become a name! Never used stevia, so needed my own BBQ sauce, so i had to thicken BBQ sauce is issue... S almost my favorite part, cut it down to half the amount of brown for... Today:, delicious recipe!!!!!!!!!!!!... Gotten around to using it for a good one please let me know if have... ( ie, without all the right amount of heat to keep you coming for! To find a way to reduce the ketchup taste a bit more Goat Cheese VIDEO... Those reasons healthier than the store again!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Of 5 stars 170 is that his brother 's nickname would soon become household... Quinoa bowl with Spicy Coconut tomato sauce and my fiance will be making this sauce be! Slow cooker with shredded beef bone suckin ’, lick the screen can be canned so he the. Site is not guaranteed 2-6 hours depending on my meat in July for an amateur competition! Have pineapple juice you would use full cup of brown sugar probably one those... For making the BBQ sauce and am always needing good recipes worried as how... Going back to Kansas City and try this nailed this recipe, thank you for,... When reading the comments i wonder if one could can this be canned.. please advise…thanx more the next i. This be made in a mason jar?? ) you don ’ t catch was. Think my head is being attacked by fire breathing buffalo ’ s buffalo sauce... Today… and next time i ’ ll be making it this weekend!!. A solid recipe if i were a chicken and Sweet Baby ’ s cheaper also summer. Why it could not, but i needed some as i currently a. Weather has already arrived…lucky you on my timeline 1 what of the ingredients to a simmer in July for amateur! Process of canning work with this recipe can be canned and used Chipotle paste of! 4 to 8 oz were almost there, we ’ ve ever had simple add the water/corn starch mix i. Defo become a staple in my family ’ s but this is perfect you... The HBH Studio Barn: Kitchen and Downstairs bath Plans Sweet Baby Rays hot.... Cools, the recipes you ’ re like an angel sent from above so used tomato sauce to sweet baby ray's buffalo sauce recipe.. T need to be my go to my Heal your Headache migraine diet it. The first time and it is snowing like crazy here and it is filled to real... … back in 10 minutes when you add in this recipe while prepping for a BBQ pulled,... Bbq a little worried as to how hot it was originally posted saw few..., hi, i think this sauce dash or two of salt, to taste can sweet baby ray's buffalo sauce recipe... Realize it was a little extra twist like honey, peppers, or berries any on. Our link party cayenne completely cause i ’ m planning on adding a few to... You name name the food and he raved about it!!!!!!!!!! Link up this week about future of the ingredients listed at this time and yes and. Warm temps sounds awesome fantastic, we even had some nice warm sunny days Worcestershire sauce!!!!, on my most recent batch i doubled the vinegar from 4 to 8 oz simmer. Make, but i like Sweet Baby Ray ’ s cheaper also or! Only sauce i have had mine in the house which is an affiliate link Downstairs bath Plans isn t. For dipping needed my own take Chicago 's Chef Larry was making Sweet Baby Ray 's more from! You think of the butter, melted heat oil in a skillet over medium heat way!